Annabelle bought a butt plug out of curiosity but it was much thicker from what it looked like on the website she bought it from and she's been too afraid to use it so when her step-dad found it in her drawer he now says her virgin asshole is about to be filled! Annabelle begs him not to do this, she is truly terrified at the thought of having that thing inside her and the ultra tight bondage isn't helping matters, her hands are raw and numb, the gag makes her drool but her step-father is undeterred and after his tied up step-daughter up on her knees, he spreads her cheeks.....and does it! Ann...

Annabelle bought a butt plug out of curiosity but it was much thicker from what it looked like on the website she bought it from and she's been too afraid to use it so when her step-dad found it in her drawer he now says her virgin asshole is about to be filled! Annabelle begs him not to do this, she is truly terrified at the thought of having that thing inside her and the ultra tight bondage isn't helping matters, her hands are raw and numb, the gag makes her drool but her step-father is undeterred and after his tied up step-daughter up on her knees, he spreads her cheeks.....and does it! Annabelle can feel the tip of the plug at her tender ass as it's slowly, excruciatingly pushed in, you can see the lube being squeezed out around the toy as it goes deeper and deeper causing the naked girl to scream past the gag in agony, she doesn't understand why her own step-father would put her through such hell but he says that this is HIS fantasy and he's going to explore it no matter how cruel it seems! Eventually the plug "pops" in her ass as it finally hits bottom, "It huuurrrtssss Step-Daddy!"she wails but instead of pulling it out he uses rope to actually crotch the thing to hold it fully in her asshole and what a sight this makes, the totally submissive girl is sobbing desperately, she loves her step-father but this is more than she ever wanted to explore with him and she wonders just how long he'll keep her in this butt plugged hell! Annabelle's reactions are 100% real, she had never had a plug that size inserted in her ass before, every gagged scream and every whimper is exactly what she endured and it's something you don't want to miss!