Brandi wakes up after having what she thought was a nightmarish night's rest. She finds out she wasn't dreaming, Randy, the guy she put a curse and cock teased to in Brandi's Curse came back for revenge in Brandi's Nightmare now he's laying beside her fully restored and she's an ugly old witch. Randy makes a pact with her, if she will fuck him he will give her back her eternal beauty and youth.