Whether it's fair or not has nothing to do with it. The fact of that matter is, Goddess Jessica is always right and if you mouth off at her for being locked in chastity too long then you can expect to get whipped. So naturally when this slave talks back to Jessica it means out comes the whip and it's time to put the male back into his place of subservience with some application of pain. Next time he will learn that the proper response is “Yes Goddess” and “Thank you Goddess”.