He comes back with several paddles and makes Naomi kneel in the armchair and stick out her lovely big round bottom, Then he takes a thick leather paddle and begins to swat her butt quite hard with it. Naomi squirms around and her ass gets even redder. After a good many swats, he exchanges the paddle for another even larger one, and by the end of the scene, we can see her butt is bruised and marked a little. But he is still not satisfied and marches off to fetch a cane.