charlott caught carmen smoking and is very unhappy but she also knows carmens is too well behaved to have done it on her own she is already going to be punished but not telling who had the cigarettes is only making it worse so charlott uses the paddles to get a confession

charlott caught carmen smoking and is very unhappy but she also knows carmens is too well behaved to have done it on her own she is already going to be punished but not telling who had the cigarettes is only making it worse so charlott uses the paddles to get a confession